A few random thoughts:
As part of my journey on the way to here, ran across an individual doing board repair and/or restoration. Dunno exactly how I found him, possibly could have been a commenter on japamacs website or somehow connected to him (Apple Discussions maybe) Anyways, he had a couple of posts on his own site about getting into that field which I found interesting. Even possible that he's a member here, don't know. I'll include the link, as it may be of use to someone, as he discusses his setup/tool kit in a couple of posts:
https://thehouseofmoth.com/logic-board-repair-two-years-later/After looking around on eBay for a bit, the thought has occurred to me that just getting another Power Mac G4 could be a fairly quick solution to the problem I was trying to solve (dead computers) The upsides are that they are relatively cheap and often a good bit more powerful than what I presently have (feeling the 1.42 DP MDD lust
) ... downsides are that they vintage now too, and likely will need repair work in the future.
While I wait for a quote on getting those two power supplies repaired, a more immediate solution would seem to be just proceeding with the ATX--->G4 PSU replacement. This would do a several things: 1. provide immediate access to one of the machines (and the files stored on it's hard drives), 2. serve to confirm whether or not I actually have a bad PSU or that it's something else, and 3. provide a back up PSU in the event of another failure in the future.
Since (theoretically) the only thing getting modified is an ATX PSU extension cable, it's a relatively cheap and easy solution to implement. A single ATX PSU could serve as a back up for multiple machines of different generations, all for the cost of ATX PSU extension cable. (IOW: about $5 or $6 bucks per PSU variation)
The only uncertainty I have at the moment is whether the +25v ADC power, which the ATX PSU lacks, plays any real part in the workings and operation of the logic board, beyond just powering an attached display.
As I mentioned in another thread, I recently got the Power 9600 fired up again with the Sonnet G4/450 installed in it. The original hard drive had 9.1 installed and I went ahead and installed OS X 10.3 on an IBM fast and wide drive I had hooked to the 9600's external SCSI bus via a 68-pin--->50-pin adapter. Would have installed 10.4 ... but I couldn't get the 9600 to see the firewire-attached DVD drive.
10.3 seemed stable - once I figured out I needed to use PostFactor slow down the processor during the early phases of booting OS X to get it to install.
However that changed when I tried to install the ATTO ExpressPCI SCSI card, so I would be able to use the Ecrix VXA-1 tape drive to to access some old back ups. While the ATTO card saw the tape drive, Retrospect didn't. So at that point I pulled the ATTO card and tried an Adaptec Power Domain 2940UW. I think at this point I've traced the tape drive problem to an issue with the Retrospect installation (requires their "Advanced Driver Kit" to use that particular device) - after reinstalling Retro it sees the tape drive - although I haven't tried to access and restore any of the VXA-1back ups yet (Just as an aside, I did use Retro to access, re-catalog, and then restore about six or eight 15 year-old back up sets that I had on DAT. It went off without a hitch and the files seem fine - which kind of surprised me, given that they had not been accessed for 15 - 20 years)
Still haven't solved the finickiness of the ATTO card ... which is kind of disappointing in that it appears that the Adaptec card definitely will not work for hosting an OS X boot drive. I'm not entirely sure whether the ATTO will either for that matter. But if it's possible I'd like to set it up that way.